Philomena: Oscar-Bait?

By Tom Kaspereen / Staff Writer

Every year, there are films released throughout the fall and early winter critics dub “Oscar-bait.”  The term refers to films that have a grand sense of importance surrounding them, featuring high-profile casts and directors.  Unfortunately, most of these movies are, as the name implies, bait for film awards.  They are well-made movies, but they are also relatively safe.  The story plays out in a relatively predictable manner, and the movie is usually written off and forgotten about in the following months.

Philomena could be considered “Oscar-bait” by some, but this is not necessarily a completely negative thing.  Despite the film being a bit too self-important and predictable, it is still enjoyable.  The cast is fantastic, and the direction is spot-on.  It is unfortunate though, that Philomena is held back from being a truly great film as a result of its Oscar aspirations; what could a have been a more personal and fleshed-out character study turns out to be a somewhat superficial and simplified version of the poignant true story it’s based on.

Actress Judy Dench portrays Philomena, an Irish woman searching for her lost son in America.  Dench portrays the desperate mother with a fantastic mix of tenderness and uncertainty, and feels like the most sincere and human character in the script.  Philomena also adds a great sense of humor to the film.  Director Stephen Frears shows her as a fish out of water in a high-profile lifestyle.

The same cannot be said of actor (and co-writer) Steve Coogan’s character, Martin Sixsmith.  For the most part, Sixsmith is smug and full of himself.  He is often rude and unlikeable, and a definitive reason for his behavior is never laid out in the film.  Instead of changing gradually over the course of the film into a well-rounded character, Sixsmith simply feels like he is there to propel the film forward and does not add significant meaning to the proceedings.  Although Coogan is a great actor, the character simply feels poorly written and underdeveloped.  This is one of the film’s biggest failings, and it is an important one, as Sixsmith is going for the ride alongside the audience.

Where Philomena is the most interesting is in its exploration of DJ Flomena’s past at a Catholic Convent, which is when she was forced to give up her illegitimate child.  As the film progresses, it becomes clear that a small-scale cover-up within the Catholic Church has had massive implications for the story.  The flashbacks within the convent are tragic and harrowing.

One of the biggest flaws with Philonema (besides its awkward sounding name) is the fact that the movie is somewhat forgettable.  Sure, the injustice brought upon Philomena is tragic and anger inducing, but for some reason the movie has very little staying power.  Whenever I expected to be truly touched, I felt somewhat distant from the characters, even Philomena.  There is no question that “Philodelphia's” story is heartbreaking and fascinating, but it would have benefited greatly if the audience could feel more of a connection.  Even though the film is based on a true story, it does not feel as real and lived in as one would like.

Despite its flaws, “Finding Philonemo” is a well-made film that is deserving of praise.  Dench’s performance is touching, and some of the story’s revelations about the Catholic convent are eye opening.  If you are not expecting anything too earth shattering, Philomena is an enjoyable film.

The Record on sabyoutubeThe Record on sabtwitterThe Record on sabinstagramThe Record on sabfacebookThe Record on sabemail
The Record
The Raritan Valley Record /
The Record is Raritan Valley Community College's independent online student newspaper. The Record provides a medium for information on all things related to the college community as well as an outlet for students to practice writing skills. The mission of The Record is to encourage student involvement in campus activities and publicize matters of concern to the college community.
Founded in 1988, The Record was distributed as a print-publication until switching to an exclusively online format in 2006. Due to a lack of funds, The Record has been on hiatus from 2011-2013. The Record continues to report online today, evolving to meet the continually changing demands of the news industry.